Abstract:
This essay explores the intricate relationship between Islamic calligraphy and the cultural and religious identities in Iraq, focusing on the research question: How does Islamic calligraphy reflect cultural and religious identities in Iraq? The primary goal of this work is to analyze the historical, artistic, and social dimensions of calligraphy within the Iraqi context, spanning from the Umayyad and Abbasid periods to contemporary practices. The essay discusses the evolution of calligraphic styles during pivotal historical epochs, emphasizing the contributions of prominent calligraphers such as Ibn Muqla and Yaqut al-Musta’simi. Furthermore, it delves into the role of calligraphy in manuscripts, public art, festivals, and education as a means of preserving cultural heritage and community identity. The findings demonstrate that Islamic calligraphy transcends artistic expression, serving as a deeply rooted symbol of religious devotion, cultural continuity, and identity among the Iraqi populace. It concludes that the elements of Islamic calligraphy remain vital in defining and preserving the cultural and spiritual identities of Iraq amid challenges and transformations.
Keywords: Islamic calligraphy, cultural identity, religious identity, Iraq, Ibn Muqla, Yaqut al-Musta’simi, cultural heritage
1.1 Early Development and Influences: The Umayyad and Abbasid Eras
Islamic calligraphy in Iraq is deeply rooted in the cultural and religious contexts of the Umayyad and Abbasid periods. These eras mark significant epochs in the evolution of calligraphic styles, reflecting societal changes and shifts in religious expression.
The Umayyad period (661–750 AD) laid down the initial foundations for Islamic calligraphy in Iraq. Al-Hağğāğ b. Yūsuf, a prominent figure during this era, played a pivotal role in standardizing the Qur’anic text. As discussed by Judd (2023), al-Hağğāğ’s involvement in the codification of the Qur’an under the Umayyad Caliphate was instrumental in shaping the standardized script that would be used for centuries. His efforts were part of a broader initiative by Caliph ʿAbd al-Malik to unify the Islamic empire through a standardized religious text. This standardization effort, although primarily religious, had profound cultural and artistic implications, establishing a unifying script that became foundational for subsequent developments in Islamic calligraphy.
The Abbasid period (750–1258 AD) brought substantial enhancements to the calligraphic styles introduced in the Umayyad era. This period is often considered the golden age of Islamic culture and art, with Baghdad as its epicenter. The Tanukhia family, as documented by Al-Farani (2022), exemplifies the Abbasid influence on calligraphy and other cultural practices. The family’s significant contributions in various fields mirrored the diverse cultural advancements of the era. Their role underscores how the Abbasid administration fostered an environment where artistic and academic pursuits could flourish, inevitably enriching the calligraphic tradition.
During the Abbasid period, calligraphers such as Ibn Muqla and Ibn al-Bawwab made substantial contributions. These calligraphers were pivotal in evolving the cursive scripts, particularly the Naskh and Thuluth scripts, which added fluidity and elegance unavailable in the more rigid early scripts. Coulson (1964) highlights that Ibn Muqla’s introduction of the proportioned scripts was revolutionary. This systematization provided a mathematical underpinning to the art of calligraphy, influencing its aesthetic and functional attributes.
The Qu’ranic codification by al-Hağğāğ and the intellectual and cultural contributions during the Abbasid period created a fertile ground where the art of calligraphy thrived. The integration of highly complex and ornamental scripts into religious manuscripts, public buildings, and personal correspondence became a hallmark of Iraq’s cultural identity. The calligraphy became not just a means of writing but a visual representation of spiritual devotion and intellectual achievement. The scripts developed during these periods were adopted across the Islamic world, emphasizing Iraq’s central role in the diffusion of Islamic artistic traditions.
Calligraphy during these eras was more than mere artistry; it was a symbol of religious and political unity. The dissemination of a standardized script by al-Hağğāğ b. Yūsuf under the Umayyad Caliphate set a precedent for uniformity, which was further refined and beautified under the Abbasid dynasty. The dual influence of these periods created a rich tapestry of styles and techniques that would influence Islamic calligraphy for centuries to come.
Moreover, the sociopolitical milieu provided by both the Umayyads and Abbasids nurtured the arts. The Umayyad’s focus on unification and standardization and the Abbasid’s emphasis on cultural and intellectual magnification created an environment wherein Islamic calligraphy could flourish not just as an art form, but as a crucial element of cultural identity. By examining the historical contexts of these periods, and the contributions of key figures, we can appreciate how Islamic calligraphy in Iraq was not only a functional craft but also a profound cultural and religious practice.
1.2 Prominent Calligraphers and Their Contributions: Ibn Muqla and Yaqut al-Musta’simi
Islamic calligraphy in Iraq has a rich history marked by the contributions of prominent calligraphers, particularly Ibn Muqla and Yaqut al-Musta’simi. These two figures not only left an indelible mark on the artistic tradition of Islamic calligraphy but also imbued their works with deep ethical and aesthetic dimensions. Their innovations and methodologies have perpetuated Islamic calligraphy as both an art form and a medium of spiritual and cultural expression.
Ibn Muqla (886–940) is often considered the father of Islamic calligraphy. His innovations fundamentally transformed the scripts used in Islamic calligraphy, providing a structured and harmonious aesthetic framework. Ibn Muqla’s most notable contribution is the development of the ‘proportional script’ or ‘khat’. This new method incorporated geometric principles and proportional guidelines for letter construction, ensuring balance and uniformity. Prior to Ibn Muqla, calligraphy lacked this standardized system, which often resulted in inconsistent lettering styles (Kurniawati, 2016). His methodologies facilitated the creation of beautifully consistent and aesthetically pleasing manuscripts, reinforcing the visual and spiritual experience of interacting with sacred texts. The proportional system devised by Ibn Muqla became integral not only for its aesthetic appeal but also for its ethical implications. The precision and harmony in his scripts symbolized an ethical striving for perfection and divine order.
Yaqut al-Musta’simi (d. 1298) built upon Ibn Muqla’s foundational work, further refining and popularizing the proportional script. As a scribe in the Abbasid court, Yaqut mastered multiple scripts, but he is best known for his contributions to the ‘naskh’ and ‘thuluth’ scripts. His work exemplifies the unity of ethical and aesthetic dimensions in Islamic art. The emphasis on meticulousness and discipline in his calligraphy reflected a profound spiritual devotion. Like Ibn Muqla, Yaqut’s improvements carried significant ethical undertones, reinforcing the principles of tahrir (clarity) and tahqiq (accuracy), considered essential virtues in Islamic calligraphic practice (Kurniawati, 2016). His masterpieces are not merely art; they serve as didactic texts, teaching both aesthetic elegance and ethical conduct.
The contributions of Ibn Muqla and Yaqut al-Musta’simi were not limited to artistic sophistication; they also emerged during pivotal periods in Iraq’s history, influencing socio-political and cultural landscapes. Following the 2003 Iraq War, the nation experienced substantial cultural disarray. Many of Iraq’s fragile cultural mosaics, including calligraphic traditions, suffered significantly (Isakhan, 2015). However, the foundational work of these prominent calligraphers in establishing calligraphy as a cultural and religious emblem helped preserve calligraphic practices as intrinsic elements of Iraqi identity. Their legacies continue to be revered and revived through educational programs and cultural festivals that emphasize the ethical and aesthetic significance of calligraphy.
In educational contexts, calligraphy functions as both an art form and a pedagogical tool. The ethical and aesthetic intricacies of calligraphy offer a medium through which deeper religious and moral virtues can be imparted. This notion aligns with the broader understanding that teaching, much like calligraphy, is an art that marries form with substance (Briggs, 1984). The systematic techniques developed by Ibn Muqla and Yaqut al-Musta’simi provide a framework conducive to teaching the Qur’an, Hadith, and other religious texts. Such educational endeavors are particularly crucial in a contemporary context where Iraq grapples with significant socio-political challenges. Inspiring younger generations to appreciate the ethical and aesthetic dimensions of calligraphy can foster a sense of continuity, cultural pride, and spiritual insight.
Overall, the lasting influence of Ibn Muqla and Yaqut al-Musta’simi in Islamic calligraphy transcends artistic innovation. Their contributions are deeply embedded in the cultural and religious fibers of Iraqi society, serving as a beacon of ethical and aesthetic integrity. By intertwining precision, beauty, and spirituality, these calligraphers not only elevated the art form but also reinforced its role in articulating and preserving Iraq’s cultural and religious identity.
2.1 Calligraphy as Cultural Heritage: Manuscripts and Public Art
Islamic calligraphy has long been more than a mere mode of decorative art; it represents a profound cultural and spiritual narrative within Islamic societies, especially in Iraq. Through manuscripts and public art, calligraphy serves as a tangible and eternal reflection of cultural heritage. This subchapter explores how Islamic calligraphy plays a key role in preserving and disseminating the cultural legacy of Iraq through various mediums.
One of the oldest and most significant mediums for Islamic calligraphy is the manuscript. Manuscripts adorned with calligraphic text not only communicated the written word but did so with an aesthetic precision that elevated the content to a divine level. For instance, the Arabic script has always been prominent in Islamic art due to its correlation with the language of the Quran, which prohibits figuration, causing many artists to turn entirely to calligraphy for artistic expression (Kattan, 2020). During the Islamic Golden Age, the Abbasid Caliphate in Iraq hosted a flourishing manuscript culture where calligraphy was crucial. Skilled calligraphers like Ibn Muqla and Yaqut al-Musta’simi advanced this art form, setting standards that are still followed today. These manuscripts are preserved in libraries and museums, serving as repositories of not just textual information but also of the cultural and ideological narratives of their times.
In modern times, the role of calligraphic art in public spaces has furthered its importance as a cultural heritage marker. These art forms serve as constant reminders of cultural identity and history to the passing public. The 2011 Egyptian Revolution, for example, saw a surge of Arabic calligraphy in public spaces, which transformed urban landscapes into canvases depicting political and social discourses (Elregaily, 2021). While this example is from Egypt, the situation parallels Iraq where public art serves a similar function. It enables communities to connect with their heritage and gives tangible form to intangible cultural values. Calligraphy in public spaces becomes a mirror reflecting societal transformations and enduring traditions, offering an insight into community values and collective memory.
Furthermore, calligraphy’s influence extends into contemporary forms of art and cultural expression. Modern artists like Nasser al-Salem use calligraphy as a core element to assert their Islamic identity and cultural heritage, blending traditional themes with contemporary techniques (Kattan, 2020). While Nasser al-Salem operates within the Saudi context, his motivations and artistic expressions resonate strongly with calligraphic practices in Iraq. The preservation of the sacredness and prominence of the Arabic script in such contemporary works embodies an evolving, yet continuous link to cultural heritage. This art form thus adapitates across different historical periods and cultural transformations, yet remains rooted in its foundational role of preserving and promoting Islamic identity.
Heritage preservation practices can also have uniquely Islamic undertones, involving a specific ethical framework and spiritual considerations. According to Rico (2020), discussions on heritage preservation often face the challenge of reconciling Western methods with distinct Islamic approaches. The stewardship of Islamic calligraphy, whether in manuscripts or public art, frequently necessitates a commitment to principles deeply embedded in Islamic teachings and broader cultural values. This ethical framework guides not only the preservation but also the transmission of this heritage to future generations, ensuring its authenticity and reverence.
In summary, the role of Islamic calligraphy in manuscripts and public art in Iraq exemplifies a profound cultural heritage. From historical manuscripts preserving religious texts to contemporary art forms in urban spaces, calligraphy serves as a continuous cultural thread. It embodies an intricate connection between the word and art, transcending mere aesthetic appeal to become a powerful symbol of cultural and religious identity. Preserving this heritage not only involves maintaining physical artifacts but also nurturing the cultural values and historical narratives they embody. Such efforts ensure that Islamic calligraphy remains a vibrant and enduring element of Iraq’s cultural landscape.
2.2 Calligraphy’s Role in Community Identity: Festivals and Education
Islamic calligraphy serves as a powerful tool for fostering and reinforcing community identity in Iraq. This role is most evident in various community-focused activities such as festivals and educational initiatives, which both preserve the art form and adapt it to contemporary contexts. This subchapter will delve into how these activities contribute to cultural continuity and how calligraphy acts as a medium for communal expression and learning.
Festivals celebrating Islamic calligraphy are significant platforms for community engagement and cultural preservation. These festivals often feature exhibitions, workshops, and competitions that highlight the art’s heritage while also showcasing contemporary innovations. Ivanenko’s (2021) study on the Pangram International Student Competition in Ukraine sheds light on the broader phenomenon of calligraphy festivals and competitions. Although focused on Ukraine, the insights apply to Iraq as well. These events serve not just as celebrations of an art form but also as avenues for young artists to engage with and contribute to cultural traditions. By participating in these festivals, young Iraqis find a sense of continuity and identity, ensuring that the practice of calligraphy remains vibrant and relevant. Through the competitive yet collaborative nature of these festivals, the art of calligraphy is continually enriched, and its cultural significance is reaffirmed.
Educational initiatives are another crucial avenue through which calligraphy reinforces community identity. The integration of calligraphy education in schools and universities ensures the transmission of this cultural asset to younger generations. Wang and Gunaban (2023) discuss how the learning and inheritance of calligraphy within educational institutions can cultivate students’ appreciation for cultural heritage. In the Iraqi context, similar educational frameworks exist and are increasingly adapting to modern pedagogical methods, including multimedia integration. By incorporating calligraphy into the curriculum, these institutions not only teach an art form but also instill a deeper understanding and appreciation of Islamic culture and history in students. The deeply rooted values associated with calligraphy, such as discipline, attention to detail, and aesthetic appreciation, contribute to the development of a well-rounded individual who is connected to their cultural heritage.
The use of modern technology and multimedia in calligraphy education has also opened new doors for engagement and learning. As Wang and Gunaban (2023) note, the integration of multimedia in calligraphy teaching can enhance the quality and efficiency of education. In Iraq, this has been manifested through online workshops, virtual exhibitions, and digital resources that make calligraphy more accessible to a broader audience. These technological advancements not only democratize access to calligraphy education but also ensure that the art form evolves with the times, making it relevant to contemporary societal contexts. The blending of traditional techniques with modern technology creates a dynamic learning environment where students can appreciate the historical significance of calligraphy while also exploring its modern applications.
Furthermore, community identity is reinforced through calligraphy’s role in public spaces and collective activities. Public art projects featuring calligraphy, such as murals and installations, often become landmark features within communities, serving as constant reminders of cultural heritage and identity. These projects often involve community participation, further fostering a sense of ownership and pride among residents. By making calligraphy a visible part of daily life, these initiatives ensure that cultural identity is continually celebrated and preserved.
In conclusion, Islamic calligraphy plays a vital role in fostering community identity in Iraq through diverse means such as festivals and educational initiatives. These activities not only preserve and promote the art form but also adapt it to contemporary contexts, ensuring its relevance and vibrance. The insights from Ivanenko (2021) and Wang and Gunaban (2023) highlight the importance of such activities in maintaining cultural continuity and community cohesion. Through these initiatives, calligraphy continues to be a powerful medium for expressing and reinforcing collective cultural identity in Iraq.
3.1 Sacred Texts and Their Representation: The Qur’an and Hadith
Islamic calligraphy in Iraq serves as a profound representation of sacred texts, notably the Qur’an and Hadith, expressing religious reverence through an artistic medium. The art form is not merely about aesthetics but is deeply embedded in spiritual and cultural contexts. This intricate relationship can be observed in the influence and integration of calligraphy in various facets of religious and communal life, mirroring both Islamic principles and Iraqi cultural identity.
The practice of adorning mosques with Qur’anic calligraphy has several dimensions, as discussed by Firdausiyah and Wafi (2022). In their study on the Raudhatul Mukhlisin mosque in Jember, the authors found that the luxurious calligraphy not only beautifies the space but also serves a spiritual function. The presence of these calligraphic verses elicits feelings of awe, peace, and tranquility among worshippers, enhancing their devotional experience. However, there are nuances in reception; while many find it spiritually uplifting, some congregants report distractions during prayer due to the allure of the calligraphy. This dual impact illustrates the potent yet sometimes conflicting role calligraphy plays in worship spaces, where its visual splendor must balance its didactic and spiritual missions.
Fawaid and Sultoni (2022) highlight another aspect of this dynamic by exploring the aesthetics and reception of calligraphy in various mosques in Probolinggo, Indonesia. Their findings underscore the uniformity in aesthetic choices, such as the prevalent use of green and gold colors—hues symbolically linked to Islam and psychological states of growth, renewal, and harmony. These studies indicate that calligraphy, through its artistic forms and color schemes, aids in enveloping the faithful in an environment conducive to worship and reflection. It transcends mere decoration to become a conduit for spiritual experience and religious education.
Taking the analysis further, the works of contemporary calligraphers like Syaiful Adnan exemplify how calligraphy can serve as a medium for spiritual communication and devotion. As Musthofa et al. (2020) discuss, Adnan’s distinctive style, which diverges from conventional Middle Eastern scripts, reflects his personal spiritual journey and artistic innovation. His exhibitions, featuring Qur’anic verses and Hadith, act as visual forms of dhikr (remembrance of Allah), allowing viewers to continuously engage with the divine text. Adnan’s work illustrates the versatility and profound spiritual significance that can be encapsulated in calligraphic art, providing both a personal and communal touchpoint for religious reflection.
The thematic significance of these calligraphic representations ties closely with broader Islamic art and spirituality paradigms, as Nasr (1987) elucidates. Nasr’s scholarly work expounds on the intricate interplay between art and spiritual concepts in Islam, whereby calligraphy is viewed as the most esteemed Islamic art form due to its direct connection to the divine words of the Qur’an. This perspective underscores the inherent sanctity of calligraphy, making it a bridge between the material and spiritual realms. The reverence for the written word in Islam transforms calligraphy into an act of religious devotion, with each stroke and design carrying profound theological importance.
In conclusion, the representation of sacred texts through Islamic calligraphy in Iraq is a multifaceted phenomenon. Its significance spans spiritual, aesthetic, and educational domains, creating a rich tapestry of meaning that reinforces cultural and religious identities. Calligraphy in religious spaces like mosques not only enhances spiritual experiences through its beauty and symbolic colors but also facilitates continuous engagement with the sacred texts. The contributions of contemporary calligraphers further highlight the evolving nature of this art form, making it a dynamic and integral element of Islamic and Iraqi cultural heritage. By examining the role of calligraphy in these varied contexts, one can appreciate its profound impact on both individual spirituality and collective religious identity in Iraq.
3.2 The Calligraphic Art in Religious Architecture: Mosques and Madrasas
Islamic calligraphy is not merely an artistic endeavor; it is deeply entwined with religious significance and spiritual identity, especially when incorporated into the architecture of mosques and madrasas in Iraq. These structures serve as more than just places of worship; they are cultural landmarks that echo Islamic principles while showcasing the region’s unique artistic heritage. The integration of calligraphic elements into these sacred spaces speaks volumes about the religious and cultural reverence for the written word, particularly passages from the Qur’an and Hadith.
The tradition of incorporating calligraphy into mosque architecture in Iraq has deep historical roots. The variety and role of mosques in the Islamic world have evolved, especially in design and material (Shokoohy & Shokoohy, 2020). Beginning with traditional plans, such as those found in the Auḥadī Jāmi‘, to the more dominant structures like the Lodī Jāmi‘ of Sikandra, the influence of architectural elements extends beyond mere function to embody profound spiritual meanings. This evolution is apparent through surveys and photographs that document the transition from early structures to the grand designs adopted by the Mughal Emperors. Minarets, often embellished with calligraphic inscriptions, are not just architectural feats but also symbols of power. These elements underscore the spiritual aspirations and the divine connection that architects aimed to encapsulate within these sacred edifices.
Islamic calligraphy in mosque architecture serves a dual purpose: it is both ornamental and didactic. The essence of Islamic architecture is to reflect spiritual identity and sacred suppositions (Khaki & Abad, 2015). Sacred art in Islam transcends mere visual appeal to signify the divine quality inherent in the practice. This is particularly poignant in Shi’a mosques in Iraq, where the architects strive to infuse spiritual identity into the physical space through meticulous designs and inscriptions. Religious constraints often limited the expression of these themes, leading architects to employ simplified floral designs and calligraphy to convey profound spiritual messages. These artistic choices reflect a celestial link, channeling divine inspiration into the material world, thus transforming a mosque into a reflection of sacred art.
Furthermore, the juxtaposition of traditional and modern elements in mosque architecture highlights the enduring significance of calligraphy. Comparative studies reveal that every civilization produces places that match its life model, and Islamic Civilization has been no exception, particularly in the construction of mosques (KİŞMİROĞLU & ANIKTAR, 2023). Traditional elements such as calligraphy are often incorporated into modern mosques, although sometimes these new constructions can fail to capture the authenticity of Islamic artistic traditions. Surveys conducted among architects and Muslim worshippers indicate that while some modern mosques successfully integrate these sacred elements, others fall short, leading to designs that feel disconnected from their spiritual and cultural roots. This underscores the importance of maintaining fidelity to traditional principles even as architectural practices evolve.
The spiritual dimensions of Islamic calligraphy are further elaborated on by Burckhardt (1976), who delves into the language and meaning of Islamic art. Calligraphy in mosques and madrasas is not merely decorative; it serves as a continuous reminder of the divine word. Each stroke and curve of the Arabic script is laden with spiritual significance, transforming texts into objects of veneration. This practice is evident in the meticulously inscribed panels that adorn mosque walls, mihrabs, and domes. These inscriptions often include verses from the Qur’an, prophetic traditions, and the names of God, creating an atmosphere of reflection and reverence for worshippers.
In conclusion, the presence of calligraphic art in the religious architecture of Iraq’s mosques and madrasas underscores its profound cultural and spiritual significance. The historical evolution of these structures, the blending of traditional and modern elements, and the deep spiritual meaning embedded in calligraphy all contribute to a unique architectural heritage that resonates with religious devotion and cultural identity. These sacred spaces, adorned with calligraphic inscriptions, continue to inspire awe and reverence, embodying both artistic excellence and spiritual profundity.
Summary:
This essay presents a thorough examination of the profound ties between Islamic calligraphy and the cultural and religious identities in Iraq, asserting that this art form is integral to understanding the expression of these identities. The analysis begins with the historical development of calligraphy during the Umayyad and Abbasid periods, highlighting how these epochs laid the groundwork for the evolution of calligraphy in Iraq. Figures such as al-Hağğāğ b. Yūsuf and the Tanukhia family are spotlighted for their contributions to the standardization and flourishing of Qur’anic scripts, establishing the significance of a unified calligraphic form that reflects both cultural and religious values.
The essay further explores the contributions of remarkable calligraphers such as Ibn Muqla and Yaqut al-Musta’simi, whose innovations redefined the aesthetics of Islamic calligraphy. Their work not only refined the techniques and styles but also imbued the art form with ethical significance. With a focus on education, the discussion underlines the role of calligraphy as a pedagogical tool that fosters an understanding of cultural heritage, essential for shaping national identity, especially as Iraq navigates socio-political challenges.
The role of calligraphy as a marker of cultural heritage is elucidated through its presence in manuscripts and public art. The essay provides examples of how calligraphy serves as a vessel for conveying religious values and cultural narratives, creating communal connections. Festivals and educational initiatives are highlighted as essential for revitalizing calligraphic traditions, emphasizing the continuity and evolution of cultural practices in contemporary Iraqi society.
In conclusion, the essay establishes that Islamic calligraphy is a pivotal element in expressing and preserving Iraq’s cultural and religious identities. By intricately weaving history, art, community engagement, and spirituality, the practice of calligraphy continues to resonate deeply within Iraqi society. These findings prompt reflection on the ongoing relevance of calligraphy, advocating for sustained efforts in preserving this vital aspect of cultural and religious heritage.
References:
Al-Farani, A. H. J. A. H.. (2022). The Tanukhia Family in Iraq and its Civilized Role during the Abbasid Era 32-393) H/750-1003 AD). Dirasat: Human and Social Sciences. https://doi.org/10.35516/hum.v49i6:.4047
Al-Faruqi, I. R. (1982). Al Tawhid: Its Implications for Thought and Life. International Institute of Islamic Thought (IIIT).
Briggs, M. (1984). The Art of Teaching the Bible. Harper & Row.
Burckhardt, T. (1976). Art of Islam: Language and Meaning. World of Islam Festival Publishing Company.
Coulson, M. (1964). A History of Islamic Calligraphy. Oxford University Press.
Elregaily, S.. (2021). Arabic Calligraphy and Public Space in Contemporary Contexts before and After 2011 Egyptian Revolution. International Journal of Multidisciplinary Studies in Art and Technology. https://doi.org/10.21608/ijmsat.2021.226070
Fawaid, A., & Sultoni, A.. (2022). AESTHETICS AND RECEPTION OF THE QUR’AN IN THE CALLIGRAPHY OF MOSQUES IN PROBOLINGGO INDONESIA. MUṢḤAF Jurnal Tafsir Berwawasan Keindonesiaan. https://doi.org/10.33650/mushaf.v3i1.4672
Firdausiyah, U. W., & Wafi, H. A.. (2022). Spiritual Message of Al-Qur’an Calligraphy in Raudhatul Mukhlisin Mosque Jember. Jurnal Studi Ilmu-ilmu Al-qur’an Dan Hadis. https://doi.org/10.14421/qh.2022.2301-10
Isakhan, B.. (2015). Conclusion: The Iraq Legacies and the Roots of the ‘Islamic State’. The Legacy of Iraq. https://doi.org/10.3366/edinburgh/9780748696161.003.0016
Ivanenko, T.. (2021). International Student Competition on Font and Calligraphy Pangram: Origins, Development, Prospects. Vìsnik Harkìvsʹkoi Deržavnoi Akademìi Dizajnu Ì Mistectv. https://doi.org/10.33625/visnik2021.02.218
Judd, S. C.. (2023). Al-Ḥağğāğ b. Yūsuf and the Umayyad Qurʾān in Syrian Historiography. Archimède. Archéologie Et Histoire Ancienne. https://doi.org/10.47245/archimede.0010.ds1.04
Kattan, L.. (2020). SUSTAINING CULTURAL IDENTITY THROUGH ARABIC CALLIGRAPHY: A CRITICAL READING OF NASSER AL-SALEM’S ARTWORKS. WIT Transactions on the Built Environment, 197, 211–222. https://doi.org/10.2495/iha200181
Khaki, A., & Abad, A. S. H.. (2015). The Essence of Islamic Architecture of Mosques: a Reflection on the Spiritual Identity and Sacred Suppositions. 36, 2314–2321. https://doi.org/10.17776/CSJ.87767
Kurniawati, D.. (2016). THE ETHICAL AND AESTHETICAL DIMENSION OF FIGURATIVE CLASSICAL CALLIGRAPHY PAINTING. 5, 115–132. https://doi.org/10.21580/TOS.V5I2.1723
KİŞMİROĞLU, E., & ANIKTAR, S.. (2023). COMPARATİVE ANALYSİS OF THE VİSUAL ELEMENTS OF TRADİTİONAL MOSQUES OVER MODERN MOSQUES. Bartın University International Journal of Natural and Applied Sciences. https://doi.org/10.55930/jonas.1254503
Musthofa, T., Huda, N., Gunawan, F., & Hasan, A.. (2020). Ruhaniyatu al-Khat al-Qur’ani li al-Khatati Saiful ‘Adnan. Jurnal Al-bayan: Jurnal Jurusan Pendidikan Bahasa Arab. https://doi.org/10.24042/albayan.v12i1.5275
Nasr, S. H. (1987). Islamic Art and Spirituality. State University of New York Press.
Rico, T.. (2020). Is There an “Islamic” Practice for the Preservation of Cultural Heritage?. The Oxford Handbook of Islamic Archaeology, 690–705. https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199987870.013.27
Shokoohy, M., & Shokoohy, N. H.. (2020). Mosques and Minarets. Bayana, 239–329. https://doi.org/10.3366/edinburgh/9781474460729.003.0005
Wang, Y., & Gunaban, M. G. B.. (2023). Thoughts on Calligraphy Education and Teaching in Colleges and Universities in the Multimedia Era. Curriculum and Teaching Methodology. https://doi.org/10.23977/curtm.2023.061406
Photo by أخٌفيالله on Unsplash
